Skip to main content

Europe · Near London, England

Sargant's wartime drug abreaction

The drug abreaction that William Sargant used in wartime Britain in the 1940s, in which patients under barbiturates or ether were driven to an emotional crescendo and collapse.

Period

1940s, with earlier precedents (Culpin in the First World War; William Brown, 1920).

Today: Ended

Evidence

Documented

Lineage

Modern lineage

During the Second World War, William Sargant and colleagues such as H. J. Shorvon treated patients broken down by Dunkirk, the Blitz, Normandy and the V-bombs. A patient was given a drug, by injection into a vein or by inhalation. As it took effect, he was made to relive the episode behind his breakdown. Fear or anger was 'deliberately induced and stimulated to a crescendo by the therapist'. Often a sudden emotional collapse followed. The patient fell back inert on the couch but soon came round, often reporting that many of his symptoms had gone.

The word abreaction, Sargant noted, went back to Breuer and Freud's early studies of hysteria, and much the same treatment had been used, mostly under hypnosis, in the First World War. Imagined scenes could work better than real ones. A man broken by a tank battle might be told, under the drug, that he was trapped in a burning tank and must fight his way out.

From 1944 the team also used ether, which released far more explosive excitement. Sudden collapse came far more often than with hypnosis or barbiturates. In war neurosis itself, Sargant noted, the upper body might shake violently while the lower part stayed still.

One afternoon he picked up his father's copy of John Wesley's Journal of 1739–1740. There he found almost identical states of excitement and collapse, brought on by preaching. 'The two techniques seemed startlingly similar.'

Watch

  • Physical Mental Health Treatments 1957, Part 1

    Mark Davis

    The fourth part of the BBC's *The Hurt Mind* (1957), 'Physical Treatment', shows doctors talking in the studio and a patient on a couch treated with an apparatus by a doctor and a nurse; no abreaction or convulsion is visible.

What kind of shaking

Sources

Where

Near London, England (placed approximately)