Europe · Vienna
Breuer and Freud's cathartic method
The method by which Josef Breuer and Sigmund Freud, in Vienna between 1880 and 1895, relieved hysterical symptoms by having patients relive a memory with its feeling and speak it out.
- Period
1880–1895, then abandoned (Freud’s 1925 account).
Today: Ended
- Evidence
Well documented
- Lineage
Independent origin
From 1880 to 1882 the Viennese physician Josef Breuer treated a young woman he called Anna O. Her real name was Bertha Pappenheim. In the evenings, under hypnosis, she talked out her hallucinations. Seriously, she called it a 'talking cure'; jokingly, 'chimney-sweeping'. The relief lasted about a day. By the second day she was 'moody, contrary and unpleasant' again, and the talk had to be repeated. She would not begin until she had made sure of him 'by carefully feeling my hands'.
In 1893 Breuer and Sigmund Freud set out the method. A symptom vanished when its memory was brought to light with its feeling. 'Recollection without affect almost invariably produces no result.' Spasms, they wrote, 're-appear once again with the fullest intensity and then vanish for ever'. The trapped feeling found 'a way out through speech'. In 1895 Freud listed 'Attacks of tremor and shivering' among the signs of anxiety neurosis.
Freud found that some patients could not be hypnotised, and turned instead to concentration and a pressure technique. One patient woke from hypnosis and threw her arms round his neck, and he gave hypnosis up. In 1925 he wrote that 'the personal emotional relation between doctor and patient was after all stronger than the whole cathartic process'.
In 1972 Henri Ellenberger published Breuer's own 1882 report, with the follow-up from a sanatorium at Kreuzlingen. Anna O. had grown used to high doses of chloral and morphine. The model case, he concluded, was 'neither a cure nor a catharsis'.
What kind of shaking
Sources
Where
Vienna (placed approximately)