North America · Barre, Massachusetts, United States
Vipassana intensive retreats
Intensive insight meditation retreats in the United States in the 1970s, on which many students shook and moved involuntarily without being told to expect it; Jack Kornfield of the Insight Meditation Society at Barre, Massachusetts, studied them.
- Period
From the 1970s.
Today: Living
- Evidence
Documented
- Lineage
Independent origin
In 1976 Jack Kornfield finished a study of students on insight meditation retreats, with data from five two-week retreats and one three-month retreat. He wrote from the Insight Meditation Society at Barre, Massachusetts, a retreat centre he had opened that year with two other young teachers, Joseph Goldstein and Sharon Salzberg. The retreats were silent, and reading, writing and music were forbidden. Students sat and walked in meditation for twelve or more hours a day. Every two days each saw a teacher, who wrote down what the student described.
Nobody told the students to expect shaking. The experiences, he wrote, were 'not encouraged, rewarded or described in advance'; the instruction was simply to sit or walk and be carefully aware. Even so, spontaneous movement was the commonest unusual experience, and more than half the questionnaires from the three-month retreat reported at least one such experience.
The students wrote: 'I felt much twitching'; 'involuntary jerks'; 'lots of shaking'; 'arms move by themselves'. One wrote of 'violent shakes, loosening, tension release'. Kornfield wrote that it was often described as 'unstressing' and 'energy release'.
A control group had the same talks but meditated only one or two hours a day, and reported only two unusual perceptions. Kornfield concluded that the experiences came 'from the retreat practice itself'. By the follow-up, months later, most altered states had vanished.
What kind of shaking
Sources
- Kornfield 1979
- Insight Meditation Society 2026 (official site)
Where
Barre, Massachusetts, United States (placed approximately)