Skip to main content

Europe · The Jewish diaspora and Eastern Europe

Jewish shokeln and early Hasidic ecstatic prayer

The rhythmic swaying of Jews at prayer and study, attested since the twelfth century, which early Hasidism in Eastern Europe made more ecstatic from the mid-eighteenth century.

Period

From the twelfth century to today; ecstatic Hasidism from the mid-eighteenth century.

Today: Living

Evidence

DocumentedSecond-hand

The Kuzari and the Rema are read in translation, and Jacob ben Asher only as quoted in the Jewish Encyclopedia.

Lineage

Independent origin

Jews have swayed the body at study and prayer since at least the twelfth century. The body bends forward and back, again and again.

Judah Halevi's Kuzari asked why Jews move to and fro when reading the Bible. One answer it reports is that 'it is done in order to arouse natural heat'. Its own answer is plainer: many once read from one large book, bending in turn, and 'it became a habit through constant seeing, observing and imitating'.

Later reasons brought trembling in. In the fourteenth century Jacob ben Asher tied swaying at study to the Torah, 'which was received with awe, trembling, and shaking'. Moses Isserles, the Rema, gave the same reason in his gloss on the Shulchan Arukh. The punctilious, he wrote, sway when reading the Torah 'in the likeness of the Torah, which was given with trembling'. At prayer they sway because of the psalm: 'All my bones shall say, Lord, who is like You?'

In Podolia and Volhynia, from the mid-eighteenth century, early Hasidism made prayer more ecstatic. A Hasidic teaching tells the worshipper first to rouse the body with all his strength, so that the power of the soul may shine forth. Afterwards he can worship 'with the mind alone, without any movements of the body'. The Vilna ban of 1772, issued shortly after Passover, charged the new Hasidim with ecstatic prayer that included twirls and somersaults. That charge came from their enemies.

Local forms

  • Early Hasidic ecstatic prayer

    Podolia, Eastern Europe · From the mid-eighteenth century; the Vilna ban came in 1772.

    From the mid-eighteenth century, early Hasidism in Podolia and Volhynia made prayer more ecstatic. A Hasidic teaching tells the worshipper first to rouse the body with all his strength, so that the power of the soul may shine forth, and afterwards to worship 'with the mind alone'. The Vilna ban of 1772 charged the Hasidim with ecstatic prayer, including twirls and somersaults, but the charge came from their enemies.

Watch

What kind of shaking

Sources

Where

The Jewish diaspora and Eastern Europe