North America · Los Angeles, California
Janov's primal therapy
A therapy developed by Janov in Los Angeles in the late 1960s that pushed patients to feel early pain again until they writhed, shook and screamed.
- Period
From the late 1960s.
- Evidence
Documented
- Lineage
Independent origin
Janov had practised insight therapy for seventeen years when a patient, Danny, ended up writhing on his office floor. Janov had asked him to call out 'Mommy! Daddy!' The writhing gave way to 'small convulsions', then 'a piercing, deathlike scream'. From this Janov built primal therapy, which he set out in The Primal Scream in 1970. He held that neurosis is repressed early pain, and that feeling it again cures.
First the patient spent twenty-four hours alone in a hotel room, with no reading, television or phone calls. Some were asked to stay up all night, because 'the sleeplessness tends to weaken his remaining defenses'. There was no rule for stopping: 'only his feelings will determine when the session ends'.
When a patient began to twitch, Janov urged, 'Feel that! Stay with it!' Deep breathing followed, with 'writhing and then shaking'. Some patients rolled off the couch onto the floor, convulsing, and in groups six or eight might be on the floor at once. One patient wrote of Primals 'lasting up to two hours in which I just shivered'.
Janov wrote that by the eighth month a patient was 'generally well', and warned that no one but 'a fully trained primal therapist' should attempt it. John Lennon and Yoko Ono underwent it in 1970. In a 1983 study, eight of eleven patients who stayed in treatment were 'definitively improved', but one had 'an affective psychosis triggered by the treatment'. A 2006 expert poll counted 'primal scream' as 'certainly discredited'.
Watch
- Primal Therapy: In Search of the Real You
A 1973 film on Janov's primal therapy: patients weep, clutch their heads and lie on padded floors in session rooms; no shaking is visible in the sampled frames.
- 1970: The PRIMAL THERAPY that inspired JOHN LENNON | 24 Hours | Weird and Wonderful | BBC Archive
BBC footage from Janov's Primal Institute: a patient writhes and sobs on the floor of a padded room with a therapist beside her, followed by interviews with Janov; no trembling is clearly visible.
What kind of shaking
- How the shaking comes: Invited, then unbidden
- What the body does: Trembling
- What the body does: Convulsions
- What the body does: Jerks
- What the body does: Falling
- What the body does: Voice
- What it is for: Therapy
- What it means: Something is let go
- What it means: A cure
- Who is there: In a pair
- Who is there: In a group
Sources
Where
Los Angeles, California (placed approximately)