Skip to main content

Europe · London and Paris

Ideomotor action and hypnosis agency

Movement felt as not one's own, named in London in 1852 and tested by Michael Faraday on table-turners in 1853, and measured in hypnosis labs since 2013.

Period

1833–1853; 2013–2019

Evidence

Documented

Lineage

Arises of itself

In 1853 people sat round tables, pressed their hands down on them, and waited for the table to move. Some put the movement down to electricity or magnetism, some to the turning of the earth, some to the devil.

Writing from the Royal Institution in London, Michael Faraday set out to test it. His sitters were honourable and, in his words, 'very desirous of succeeding'. He reported their view: 'all agree that the table moves the hands and not the hands the table'. Faraday tied a bundle of sandpaper, glass, clay, tinfoil and other materials under their hands, and the table still turned.

Next he built an indicator: two thin boards on glass rollers, with a long hay-stalk lever to show the first push of the hand. With the index hidden, it showed their hands creeping in the agreed direction, while they believed they pressed straight down. When they could watch the index, no motion came at all. The movement, Faraday wrote, was 'checked in the commencement'. He judged the cause to be 'a quasi involuntary muscular action'.

A year earlier, in 1852, W. B. Carpenter had coined a word for movement prompted by an idea: 'ideo-motor'. In Paris, Michel Eugène Chevreul had written on the swinging pendulum as early as 1833. Faraday describes no trembling in his sitters; they pushed and drifted. In 2013, hypnosis researchers published a scale to measure how involuntary such a movement feels.

Watch

What kind of shaking

Sources

Where

London and Paris (placed approximately)