Skip to main content

North America · Big Sur, California, United States

Encounter groups

Intense group meetings for personal growth, run at the Esalen Institute in California and far beyond it in the 1960s and 1970s; a 1969 Stanford study counted their casualties.

Period

The 1960s and 1970s.

Today: Ended

Evidence

Well documented

Lineage

Independent origin

Michael Murphy and Dick Price founded the Esalen Institute in 1962, and Will Schutz ran encounter groups there. In 1969 an Esalen encounter workshop was named after kundalini, the 'serpent' of energy potential. Three researchers, Lieberman, Yalom and Miles, called the style drawn from Schutz's book Joy 'Esalen Eclectic'. It set out to free members from muscular and social inhibitions. Through manuals such as Joy, they wrote, 'untold numbers' had closed their eyes and let themselves fall backwards, as an exercise in trust.

In the spring of 1969 the three studied encounter groups for students at Stanford University. Sixteen leaders, chosen as among the best in the Bay Area, ran groups in nine styles, with thirty hours for each group. Of the 206 students who began, 16 'suffered significant psychological injury', a rate near 10 per cent that the authors called 'alarming and unacceptable'. Ten of these had been hurt by an attack from the leader or from the group. Aggressive, charismatic leaders, whom the authors called 'Energizers', had seven casualties among fifty-nine members; supportive 'Providers' had one among thirty-seven, and the most learners. The data, they wrote, lent 'little credence to the notion that high risk is necessary' for growth.

Kripal's history of Esalen records no trembling in the encounter groups. The tremors it does mention belong elsewhere, such as the 'spontaneous tremors' of Christina Grof's shaktipat initiation. In 1975 Levine's workshop at Esalen announced that it was 'not directed toward explosive discharge or group encounter'.

Watch

  • Carl Rogers - Journey into Self

    MMHCA Library

    Carl Rogers's 1968 encounter-group film, with close-up shots of a participant's face moving through emotional expression during a session; no trembling is shown.

What kind of shaking

Sources

Where

Big Sur, California, United States (placed approximately)