Skip to main content

Global · Worldwide

Dissociative seizures

Attacks that resemble epilepsy, sometimes with convulsive shaking, treated in modern medicine worldwide and most reliably diagnosed by recording a seizure on video-EEG; they descend from the hysteria of Charcot's Salpêtrière.

Period

Modern: the descendants of Charcot's hysteria.

Today: Living

Evidence

ThinSecond-hand

The modern condition is known from clinical papers, one trial read in full and the rest in their published abstracts, and its Charcot ancestry from two later histories.

Lineage

Arises of itself

Dissociative seizures are attacks that resemble epilepsy or fainting, and some are convulsive. The most reliable test is to record a seizure on video-EEG, which films the body while tracing the brain's electrical activity. Side-to-side movements of the head or body and closed eyes are among the signs.

Their names have moved from hysteria to psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES), and then to dissociative or functional seizures. The line runs back to Charcot's Salpêtrière, in Paris. Charcot named the condition hystero-epilepsy. In the historian Georges Didi-Huberman's account, Charcot set out 'the great hysterical attack' in four phases, the first 'the epileptoid phase, mimicking or "reproducing" a standard epileptic fit'.

New cases are put at 1.4 to 4.9 per 100,000 people a year. Most of those diagnosed are women: 67.6 per cent in one six-country series. Trauma is common in their histories, at 44 to 100 per cent in the samples reviewed, and abuse at 23 to 77 per cent.

The agreed treatment is a careful explanation of the diagnosis, followed by psychotherapy. The CODES trial tested cognitive behavioural therapy with 368 patients, recruited at 27 UK services. At twelve months the therapy had not significantly reduced how often the seizures came, but it had made them less bothersome and lengthened the seizure-free spells. It also improved quality of life and lessened distress.

What kind of shaking

Sources

Where

Worldwide